News RSS Feed


Daschund facing dangerous dog death sentence

9:50am Monday 22nd January 2007

comment Comments (21)   Have your say »


A MINIATURE sausage dog is facing a possible death sentence after nipping a neighbour's ankle.

At 8ins in height Lucy the Daschund doesn't look the most fearsome of creatures.

But she faces being destroyed under the Dangerous Dogs Act if owner Melanie Hobson is convicted of allowing her to run amok.

Mother-of-two Melanie appeared at Newcastle Magistrates Court last week where she pleaded not guilty to having a dog dangerously out of control in a public place.

Melanie, who faces a fine and the prospect of Lucy being destroyed if found guilty, has now spoken out in defence of her dog.

The 25-year-old mum from Gosforth, Newcastle, said: "I've never been to court before and I found it very intimidating.

"I can't believe this is happening. Lucy is a lovely dog and I would never have her round my kids if I thought she was dangerous.

"You only need to look at her, she's tiny, how can she be classed as a dangerous dog?

"I just want this whole nightmare to be over, I can't bear the thought of Lucy being put down, I don't know how I would break that to the kids, they love her."

Full time mother Melanie lives with her husband Stephen, 33, and their two children Monique, two, and Jacob, four.

"The kids adore Lucy and to be honest they drag her all over the place.

"She's kind and gentle with them and incredibly patient.

"I just can't emphasise enough how tiny she is."

Melanie said on October 9, the day of the alleged attack, she was carrying shopping into her home at 3.45pm while her children and Lucy ran in front of her.

"Next thing I know our neighbour accuses Lucy of biting him on the ankle.

She's never done anything like that before."

A week later the police knocked on Melanie's door to take a statement from her.

"When they saw how big Lucy was you could see in their faces they thought 'what are we doing here?' "I thought that would be the last of it but then I got the court summons and I was absolutely petrified."

Melanie said she felt like a criminal when she appeared at magistrates court and found the whole experience frightening.

"It was awful, I'm not a criminal. On the face of it, it is funny - I mean a sausage dog a dangerous dog?

"But then the reality is I'm in court and the children could lose their best friend if Lucy is put down.

"I know the authorities are having to be careful at the moment because of all the news about dangerous dogs but everybody I've spoken to about it find it hard to believe."

Melanie now faces a trial later this year.


Your Say YourNorth-East

Bill, says...
2:23pm Mon 22 Jan 07

An Anti BSL Downing Street petition!

http://petitions.pm.gov.uk/deedNOTbreed/

Richard, says...
4:20pm Mon 22 Jan 07

Absolutely ridiculous, I fear that an example is being made of Lucy the dog. How can a sausage dog that small be dangerous?!! Not sure on the full story but if there is no evidence of the dog breaking the skin of the person it bit then there is no proof it even happened! Good luck Melanie!

Sue, says...
5:21pm Mon 22 Jan 07

any dog can be a danger, even the small ones have teeth and bite.
It's classed as funny when a toy dog dose it, but its not they do harm,i agree not as much as a big dog, but had it bitten a child or a baby the result could be the same as a big dog.why is it that a toy dog because it's small can get away with what a medium, large or giant breed can't size makes no diffrence

Brian Wohlgemuth, says...
9:06pm Mon 22 Jan 07

Don't you guys play rugby over there? It's probably the right size and weight....

j/k people. Little dogs can be really vicious, but really don't cause any damage otherwise. A good shove with the foot usually solves the problem.

Jason Law, says...
11:09pm Mon 22 Jan 07

Any dog of any size can be dangerous. People are quick to condemn certain breeds yet studies have shown the breeds most highlighted by the media actually bite way less than other more common breed such as Labs,Collies and Spaniels. Small dogs can be a nuicence and their owners must realize this fact. A dog bite is a dog bite,plain and simple. If the dog has biten this person they will need medical back up to prove so. If their is no medical evedence of a dog bite there is no case.

mel page, says...
11:54pm Mon 22 Jan 07

Indeed ANY breed can be classed as dangerous, they just generally target larger or more powerful breeds.. www.deednotbreed.org.uk are having an awareness day and protest in LIVERPOOL CITY CENTRE
Melanie I hope you don't lose your dog. Sadly many many people are in a similar position right now and their dogs HAVEN'T bitten.
Bill, thanks for the petition link.

mel page, says...
11:56pm Mon 22 Jan 07

that was supposed to read Williamson Square 12-2pm sat 27th. or visit the website www.deednotbreed.org.uk

Julie Butler, says...
2:54pm Wed 24 Jan 07

We have a miniature daschund too. They are a yappy dog I agree but certainly not vicious! However, I would question why she bite the neighbour - was it because she was doing her job and protecting her owner/property? Did the neighbour kick out at the dog so she was protecting herself. they don't bite for nothing.

Paul Haggath, says...
3:38pm Wed 24 Jan 07

I like sausages.. but ones that bite babies should be put down in mu opinion. Was that picture taken shortly before it savaged the child in a frenzied attack!? Wow, she has no idea that she's dicing with death!

Christie Lafranconi, says...
3:44pm Wed 24 Jan 07

We own a dachshund and yes, he can be a bit yappy at times, but he can barely open his mouth wide enough to eat his dinner and bark...think it's the same for the whole breed...so he could Lucy "nip an ankle" and caused injury. Perhaps the question should better be what did the neighbor do to upset Lucy enough to act out in this manner?

lesley s, says...
8:06pm Thu 25 Jan 07

we have 3 mini dachshunds yes these dogs do bark and its harder than there bite!ours are brought up with children and would never bite,what has the neighbour done to upset lucy,dont let lucy be made a example of these dogs are not dangerous,good luck for lucy.

farley gordon, says...
7:12am Wed 31 Jan 07

we have two dachunds there the best dogs you can have . some times are bit when playing but it dont hurt . we need to do something with the one that do bit . mybe the courts will make you keep her inside .best of luck my god blest you

Rachel Cartwright, Midlands says...
1:36pm Fri 2 Feb 07

This is so contradictory and just proves that condemning certain breeds is a load of rubbish, advocated by people without a clue about dogs. This dog bit someone, yet you're all defending it. Yet Staffies and Rotties are hated even when they do nothing wrong! If this "nip" was given by a Staffie, you'd be all over it. You can't have one rule for dogs you think are cute, and a different law for those you think are scary. Say no to Breed Specific Legislation.

Lorina Eyre, Chesterfield says...
8:24pm Sat 3 Feb 07

I think that this owner and dog should definitely have a warning rom the court. It is not acceptable for any dog, large, medium or small to bite. This little dachund was more than likely doing its best to defend its property/people and as such could be considered to be out of control. I have known many small dogs whose owners think it "cute" to allow aggressive behaviour, saying that they are too small to be any danger. However, I don't think "too small" can be given as an excuse. If the dog is frightened and bites it should be better socialised. If it is acting protectively then it should be re-trained. Some little dogs can be absolute horrors and get away with bad behaviour and lack of training that would not be tolerated in a larger dog. There should be one law for all, size has nothing to do with it.

deb tester, swansea says...
7:22pm Sun 25 Feb 07

It would be great if the police were so good when it came to dangerous neighbours, can your neighbour produce any evidence

patricia fox, tennessee says...
9:52pm Fri 16 Nov 07

this is the most stupidest thing i ever heard
i too have a dachund eli as matter of fact my sister breed them she has 9of them they are great little dog and i do say little eli nips when he playing but never bite hard enough to do any damage i would ask to see where lucy bit him they are too small to hurt anyone he just a big crybaby or hates dogs good luck lucy
hope it works out for you please email me and let me know what happens my grandson only 18months ols play with eli all the time they play rough but eli never hurts him i know how your family feels

Emily, Minnesota says...
4:14pm Tue 20 Nov 07

This case is just the proof we need to show people that breed laws and "dangerous" dog acts are getting out of control.

toni cortes, philippines says...
11:18pm Mon 28 Jan 08

i got a daschund x shitzu and she is suppose to be 4 months now apparently she died bcoz of parvovirus(killer of puppies. TRIXIE name of my puppy is a very small cute and playful puppy.evrybody loves her in our neighborhood.she bit me once bcoz she defended herself from me bcoz i accidently stepped on her...i believe all dogs, cats and other animals have an instinct of biting to defend themselves.its their nature...yes we train them but still they forgot all those trainings and stuff whwen they know that tehy are in danager...i believe a puppy or dog will not bite if it was not hurt...it will not do something that will hurt human if he knows everything 's fine...and it is not right to put a puppy downbcoz he bit somebody bcoz we all know that we are more powerful than animals. they arte just protecting themselves..
i plead NOT GUILTY for the puppy...:">

Brad Littlefield, Hollywood, California says...
1:07am Wed 30 Jan 08

I had a wonderful longhaired daschund, Dotti Hinkle - the sweetest, most loving animal I've ever owned. She attacked a letter carrier, giving her a painful and severe bite on the back of her knee, punctured a major vein, causing severe injuries. A few months later, she died of osteo-carcenoma (bone cancer). It turned out the pain caused a change in her behavior. It was very sad. I would like to offer a volunteer home for the daschund mentioned in this article, if the courts would allow her to go to a foster home, as opposed to being put down. I would be willing to pay transport costs, vet bills, customs fees, etc. My email is brad.littlefield@gma
il.com and my cell is 562.552.3127 - sincerely, Brad Littlefield

cheryl grant, newcastle says...
3:13pm Tue 5 Feb 08

lucy the dog was a lovely dog a looked afta it all the time and it wudnd harm a fly. it was a lazy dog. and it loved kids

N Rippon, South Shields says...
3:46pm Tue 10 Jun 08

Paul Haggath wrote:
I like sausages.. but ones that bite babies should be put down in mu opinion. Was that picture taken shortly before it savaged the child in a frenzied attack!? Wow, she has no idea that she's dicing with death!
Erm did you not read the article? It bit an adult neighbour not a child!

Your sayYourNorth-East

comment Add your comment

Register for a FREE The Northern Echo account and you can have your say on today's news and sport by adding comments on articles we publish. The best comments may even get published in the paper.

Please register now or sign in below to continue.




Forgotten your password?
Lucy the Daschund pictured with two-year-old Monique Hobson Lucy the Daschund pictured with two-year-old Monique Hobson

Sponsored Links


Local Advertisers


Local Information

Enter your postcode, town or place name

House prices »   Schools »   Crime »   Hospitals »